Truth in Medicine

Trust & Misinformation

The claim

“People don't trust doctors anymore, so they get their health advice from social media.”

The short answer

Trust in doctors as a group has dropped a long way since 2020, and lower trust goes with lower vaccination. But 85% of Americans still trust their own doctor, health care providers are still the most-used and most-trusted source of health information, and social media mostly adds to what people hear from doctors. It hasn't replaced them.

Trust in doctors really has fallen. Most Americans still go to their own doctor first.

The share of Americans with a lot of trust in physicians and hospitals fell from 72% to 40% between 2020 and 2024. Here's who lost trust and why, some of it for fair reasons, how many people really get health advice from social media, and what the evidence says rebuilds trust.

Why the claim feels right

If it feels as though trust in doctors has collapsed, that isn't your imagination. By several measures it has.

The largest study, published in JAMA Network Open in 2024, surveyed more than 443,000 American adults in all 50 states between April 2020 and January 2024. At the start of the pandemic, 71.5% said they had "a lot" of trust in physicians and hospitals. By January 2024, that had fallen to 40.1%.

Gallup, which has asked Americans to rate the honesty and ethics of different professions for decades, tells a similar story. In 2020, a record 77% rated doctors' honesty and ethics high or very high. By late 2024 that was down to 53%, the lowest since the mid-1990s. It recovered a little, to 57%, in Gallup's December 2025 poll, still 20 points below the pandemic peak and below where it was before COVID.

Pew Research Center sees the same shape for scientists. In April 2020, 87% of Americans had at least a fair amount of confidence that scientists act in the public's best interests. In Pew's most recent survey it was 77%. Pew says its ratings of medical scientists are very similar to its ratings of scientists in general.

So the first half of the claim has real data behind it. What doesn't hold up is the jump to the second half: that people have given up on doctors and moved to social media instead.

Trust was slipping before COVID

The pandemic made the drop sudden. But American trust in medicine had been weak for a long time.

In 2014, researchers writing in the New England Journal of Medicine reviewed decades of polling. In 1966, 73% of Americans said they had great confidence in the leaders of the medical profession. By 2012, 34% did.

They also compared the US with other countries, using a survey of 29 nations carried out between 2011 and 2013. According to HealthDay's report on the study, 58% of Americans agreed that, all things considered, doctors in their country can be trusted. That put the US in a tie for 24th of 29. In Switzerland, Denmark and several other countries, three-quarters or more agreed.

Here is the part that's easy to miss. In the same survey, the US ranked third on patients' satisfaction with their own medical care. Americans were fairly happy with the care they got, and fairly distrustful of the profession as a whole. That split comes up again and again in this data.

Who lost trust

The fall wasn't spread evenly.

In the 50-state study, lower trust in 2023 was more common among people aged 25 to 64, women, people with less education or lower incomes, Black Americans, and people living in rural areas. Trust fell in every group the researchers looked at.

Politics is a big part of the story too.

  • Gallup: before the pandemic, Republicans and Democrats rated doctors' ethics almost identically. By 2022, Democrats' ratings of doctors had recovered to above their pre-pandemic level, while Republicans' were significantly lower. In the December 2025 poll, Democrats rated doctors 16 points higher than Republicans did.
  • Pew: Republicans' confidence in scientists fell 22 points between April 2020 and December 2021. In Pew's latest survey, 90% of Democrats and 65% of Republicans had at least a fair amount of confidence in scientists.
  • KFF: between June 2023 and January 2025, the share of Republicans who trusted their own doctor to make the right recommendations dropped from 94% to 84%.

The partisan gap is real, but it isn't the whole explanation. The study linking trust to vaccination, below, found the link held even after accounting for party.

The reasons people give, and some of them are fair

It's tempting to blame all of this on misinformation. The people who lost trust tell a more complicated story, and a fair amount of it is about real problems in American health care.

In the 50-state study, researchers asked 200 people with low trust why. The answers:

  • 35% said doctors and hospitals put financial motives ahead of patient care
  • 27.5% pointed to poor quality of care or negligence
  • 13.5% cited the influence of outside groups or agendas
  • 4.5% described discrimination or bias

A 2021 survey of 2,069 adults by NORC at the University of Chicago, for the ABIM Foundation, asked people who didn't trust their own doctor for the main reason. A quarter, 25%, said the doctor spent too little time with them. Another 14% said doctors don't listen to them or know them.

Cost runs underneath much of this. The 2014 review found 65% of Americans saw high health care costs as a very serious problem for the country, and lower-income Americans were significantly less trusting of physicians. NORC found the same gradient with people's own doctors: 66% of adults with household incomes under $30,000 trusted their primary doctor, against 89% of those on $100,000 or more. Black (71%) and Hispanic (68%) adults reported lower trust in their primary doctor than White adults (82%).

As an emergency physician, I don't think any of those answers are unreasonable. A 10-minute visit, a surprise bill, or a doctor who never looks up from the screen are real experiences, not conspiracy theories. Distrust that grows out of them isn't irrational, even when the conclusions people draw from it are wrong.

"Not doctors. The system."

This is where the claim really breaks down. When people say they don't trust doctors, much of the distrust seems to be aimed at the system around the doctor, not the person in the exam room.

The NORC survey asked the public how much they trusted each part of health care:

Who Trust completely or somewhat
Nurses 85%
Doctors 84%
Hospitals 72%
The health care system as a whole 64%
Government agencies 56%
Pharmaceutical companies 34%
Health insurance companies 33%

The people delivering care sit at the top. The institutions that set prices and pay the bills sit at the bottom.

And the pandemic barely moved how people felt about the doctor they see most. In that same survey, taken in early 2021, 77% said COVID hadn't changed their trust in that doctor, 11% said it had gone up and 12% said it had gone down.

KFF's polling points the same way. In 2023, 93% of adults trusted their own doctor at least a fair amount to make the right recommendations for their health. That slipped to 85% by January 2025, and KFF reported that doctors remain the most trusted source of health information.

One caution. You'll often hear that people trust "my doctor" far more than "doctors". The 85% from KFF and the 40% from the 50-state study can't be compared directly: they asked different questions, on different scales, of different people. The one survey I found that asked both on the same scale, NORC's, found similar numbers: 84% trusted doctors in general and 78% trusted their own primary doctor. The clearer, better-supported gap is between clinicians and the health care system.

How many people get health advice from social media?

Quite a lot, but mostly alongside their doctor, not instead.

Pew asked more than 5,000 adults in October 2025 where they get health information. 85% said they get it from health care providers at least sometimes, more than any other source. 36% said the same about social media, and 22% about AI chatbots. Most people use several sources: 73% use three or more.

Younger adults lean on social media much more. 52% of adults under 30 get health information there at least sometimes, against 21% of those 65 and older. Uninsured Americans are more likely than insured Americans to turn to social media, and less likely to get information from health care providers. That's worth noticing: some of the move to social media is about who can easily get in to see a doctor.

KFF's numbers, from a July 2025 poll that asked the question differently, are higher: 55% of adults use social media for health information at least occasionally, and 22% do so at least weekly. A separate Pew study found 4 in 10 adults, and half of those under 50, get health and wellness information from social media influencers or podcasts. KFF found 14% of the public, and 23% of 18- to 29-year-olds, regularly get health information from influencers.

But using it isn't the same as trusting it:

  • Of people who get health information from social media, just 7% rate it highly accurate, and 47% say it's not too or not at all accurate. For health care providers, 65% rate the information highly accurate and 4% say it isn't accurate.
  • Only 10% of people who follow health influencers trust all or most of what they hear from them.
  • In KFF's poll, 61% of those who get health information from influencers think the influencers are mostly motivated by money.
  • More people who follow health influencers say what they hear is not very different from what their doctors tell them (38%) than say it is extremely or very different (18%).

The picture isn't a public that abandoned doctors for TikTok. It's a public that still goes to doctors first, scrolls past a lot of health content, and isn't sure how much of it to believe. Half of Americans told Pew it's at least somewhat difficult to judge whether health information is accurate.

Why falling trust matters: vaccines

Trust isn't just a feeling. In the 50-state study, it tracked what people did.

Compared with people who had no trust in physicians and hospitals, people with a lot of trust had about 5 times the odds of having had a COVID vaccine (adjusted odds ratio 4.94) and of having had a flu vaccine (5.09), and about 3.6 times the odds of having had a COVID booster (3.62). Those links held after the researchers accounted for political party and other characteristics.

That doesn't prove low trust caused people to skip vaccines. People who distrust doctors may differ in other ways, and the authors are clear that the study shows an association. The survey also wasn't a random sample, and the wording of the trust question changed partway through. But its direction matches Gallup's and Pew's, and the stakes are clear. When trust falls, preventable illness becomes more likely.

What rebuilds trust

The evidence here is thinner than the evidence on the decline, so I'll stick to what it actually shows.

Time and listening. In the NORC survey, people with high trust in the health care system were much more likely to say their doctor spends enough time with them (80% vs 61%) and cares about them (79% vs 52%) than people with low trust. Almost all physicians (98%) said spending enough time with patients matters for trust, yet only 77% of patients felt their doctor did.

A direct recommendation. Your own doctor is still the most trusted voice, and it shows. In a national study of the 2016–17 flu season, 66.6% of adults whose provider both recommended and offered a flu shot got vaccinated, compared with 48.4% of those who were only told about it and 32.0% of those who got neither. That's an association too, but it's a strong one.

Expertise, openness and plain language. When Pew asked what people want from a source of health information, 75% said medical training on the topic was highly important, 73% said being open about conflicts of interest, and 72% said being easy to understand.

Standing with patients on cost. The authors of the 2014 review argued that the profession could earn back public trust by taking visible stands on policies that improve health care, including tackling high costs, even when those policies don't benefit doctors themselves. That's an argument, not a tested intervention, but it speaks directly to the most common reason people gave for distrust: money.

As an emergency physician, here's my takeaway. Trust gets rebuilt in the exam room, one visit at a time. It isn't rebuilt by telling people they're wrong to have doubts.

The bottom line

Trust in doctors as a group has fallen sharply since 2020, and it was weak by international standards long before that. The drop was steepest among some groups, it has a strong partisan streak, and lower trust goes with lower vaccination rates.

But "people don't trust doctors, so they use social media instead" gets the evidence backwards. 85% of Americans still trust their own doctor, health care providers remain the most-used and most-trusted source of health information, and only 7% of people who get health advice from social media think it's highly accurate. Most of the distrust is aimed at cost, rushed visits and the system around the doctor, and some of that criticism is fair.

If you've lost faith in "the medical system," that's understandable. Before you replace your doctor with a feed, try asking your doctor the question you were going to ask the internet.

Sources

  1. Perlis RH, Ognyanova K, Uslu A, et al. Trust in Physicians and Hospitals During the COVID-19 Pandemic in a 50-State Survey of US Adults. JAMA Netw Open. 2024;7(7):e2424984.
  2. Brenan M. Nurses Continue to Lead in Honesty, Ethics Ratings. Gallup, 12 January 2026.
  3. Saad L. Americans' Ratings of U.S. Professions Stay Historically Low. Gallup, 13 January 2025.
  4. Brenan M. Nurses Retain Top Ethics Rating in U.S., but Below 2020 High. Gallup, 10 January 2023.
  5. Blendon RJ, Benson JM, Hero JO. Public Trust in Physicians — U.S. Medicine in International Perspective. N Engl J Med. 2014;371(17):1570–1572.
  6. Norton A. Americans Show Distrust of Medical Profession in Survey. HealthDay, 22 October 2014.
  7. Pew Research Center. Public Trust in Scientists and Views on Their Role in Policymaking. 14 November 2024.
  8. Kennedy B, Kikuchi E. Americans' confidence in scientists. Pew Research Center, 15 January 2026.
  9. Pasquini G, Stocking G, Kikuchi E, Pula I, Yam E. Where Do Americans Get Health Information, and What Do They Trust? Pew Research Center, 7 April 2026.
  10. Stocking G, Widjaya R, Lieb A, Radde K, Smith A, Yam E. Moms, Coaches, Doctors, Entrepreneurs: Who Are America's Health and Wellness Influencers? Pew Research Center, 7 May 2026.
  11. KFF. KFF Health Misinformation Tracking Poll Pilot. 22 August 2023.
  12. KFF. KFF Tracking Poll on Health Information and Trust: January 2025. 28 January 2025.
  13. KFF. KFF Health Information and Trust Tracking Poll: Health Information and Advice on Social Media. 7 August 2025.
  14. NORC at the University of Chicago for the ABIM Foundation. Surveys of Trust in the U.S. Health Care System. May 2021.
  15. Lu PJ, Srivastav A, Amaya A, et al. Association of provider recommendation and offer and influenza vaccination among adults aged ≥18 years – United States. Vaccine. 2018;36(6):890–898.

Found this useful? Pass it on.

← All posts